SC judges' revolt LIVE UPDATES: Bar Council calls for immediate resolution of SC crisis, offers to mediate
- SC judgesâ revolt LIVE UPDATES: Bar Council calls for immediate resolution of SC crisis, offers to mediate
Supreme Court judges vs CJI Live Updates: A day after four top SC judges held a press conference to reveal that "things are not in order" within the judiciary, we bring you all the reactions and news.Supreme Court judges vs CJI LIVE UPDATES: Justices Jasti Chelameswar, Ranjan Gogoi, Madan B Lokur and Kurian Joseph address a press conference in New Delhi on Friday (Express Photo/Abhinav Saha)
In an unprecedented move on Friday, four top judges of the Supreme Court held a press conference during which they questioned the conduct of the Chief Justice of India Dipak Misra, especially over the allocation of cases. Justices Jasti Chelameswar, Ranjan Gogoi, Madan B Lokur and Kurian Joseph â" who make the current Supreme Court Collegium, the highest decision-making body of the judiciary â" said they had failed to persuade CJI Dipak Misra that certain things are not in order, and left it to the people to protect the judiciary. They warned that democracy was under threat.
The government, in response, maintained that the matter will be sorted out within the judiciary and that the press conference âcould have been avoided.â Meanwhile, the Opposition took note of the âdisturbingâ and âextremely seriousâ allegations.
Missed out on what happened yesterday? Read highlights here.
Below are the LIVE UPDATES:
6:08 PM: BCI Chairman said, âPrime Minister and law minister had said yesterday itself that it is judiciaryâs internal matter and govt wonât be interfering in the matter, and we appreciate the governmentâs stand.â
6:06 pm: The decision to form a seven-member committee comes after a meeting of the Bar Council of India. The Council appreciated the government decision to not comment on the matter.
6:04 pm: As far as MOP is concerned, it must be finalised at the earliest in a proper manner. We will write a letter to the govt for the same but is not that big a matter to be brought in public: BCI Chairman.
6:02 pm: BCI Chairman, without naming Congress, urged political parties to not politicise the issue to gain mileage and damage the democracy.
6:00 pm: Manan Kumar Mishra, chairman of Bar Council of India says Council ready to mediate the judiciary crisis.
5:59 pm: Bar Council calls for internally resolving the issues raised by the SC judges.
5:58 pm: The Bar Council forms a 7-member delegation of the Council who will meet judges of the Supreme Court over the issue.
5:51 pm: Congress today said Prime Minister Narendra Modi must answer as to why a âspecial messengerâ was sent to the CJI, reported PTI.
5:35 pm: The press conference held by the four top judges of the SC was first of its kind in the history of independent India and has created ripples, revealing the growing unease among judges with the manner of funct ioning of the top court.
5:28 pm: Meeting of Bar Council of India is underway in Delhi. The members will shortly address a press conference over the feud going on in the Supreme Court between the judges and CJI Dipak Misra.
1.51 pm: Congress spokesperson Randeep Singh Surjewala says the Prime Minister should respond to why his principal secretary Nripendra Misra visited the CJIâs residence. Taking to Twitter, he said, âAs PMâs Principal Secretary, Nripendra Misra visits CJIâs residence at 5, Krishna Menon Marg; PM must answer the reason for sending this special messenger to Chief Justice of India.â
1.06 pm: The chairman of the Bar Council of India, Manan Kumar Mishra, says the meeting will take place at 5 pm this evening, and tomorrow a delegation will meet senior judges and the CJI and request them to refrain from telling the public about internal issues. Speaking to ANI, he says, âHoldi ng a PC on a minor issue of roster is saddening. We have a meeting at 5 pm today & tomorrow our delegation will meet those senior judges, CJI & other judges & request them to not bring issues like these in front of public.â
12.35 pm: The Supreme Court Bar Association will meet sometime this afternoon. It will hold a press conference at 6 pm to address the allegations made by the four judges yesterday. The president of the association had told ANI this morning that the press conference yesterday was ânot properly plannedâ and has created âdoubts in the minds of people.â
12.11 pm: Hereâs EP Unnyâs cartoon in todayâs The Indian Express. For more cartoons, click here.
11.47 am: In response to th e developments yesterday, the Congress had stated that the judgesâ concerns are âextremely important.â The party supported the judgesâ view that âestablished conventions and traditions of the courts must be followed, and selective assignment of cases must be stoppedâ. Read more here.Congress President Rahul Gandhi addressing the media over the judiciary crisis at AICC HQ. (Source: INC)
11.24 am: Justice Joseph, following the meeting, said the issues raised by the judges were not âpersonalâ but âinstitutional.â He expressed confidence that they would be resolved soon and hoped the customary Monday meeting of the four judges with the CJI would take place. Hereâs what he said to The Indian Express.
Also read | Govt vs Supreme Court is now Judges vs CJI
11.08: Attorney General K K Venugopal, while leaving his residence this morning, says, âlet us hope everything goes down very well.â Yesterday, he had said the press conference by the judges âcould have been avoided.â
11.00 am: Former Chief Minister Omar Abdullah, this morning, in a series of tweets, says the judgeâs questions should concern every single Indian as democracy is the bedrock of our nation. He tweeted, ââDemocracy in India is in dangerâ. This was the warning that came from the Hon Judges yesterday. So no, itâs not an internal matter for the Hon SC. It is certainly not a BJP v/s Congress or a Rahul v/s Modi issue. It is quite simply an issue that should concern every single Indian.â
âDemocracy in India is the bedrock of our nation. We take pride in telling the world we are the largest democracy even if we arenât the oldest or the greatest. When four senior most Hon judge s of the Supreme Court see a threat to Indiaâs democracy the worst thing we can do is to simply wish it away,â he added.
Read | In letter, judges say govt silent on memorandum of procedure, means it accepted it
10.49 am: Nripendra Misra, the principal secretary to the Prime Minister, has called on Chief Justice of India Dipak Misraâs residence in New Delhi, reports ANI.
10.36 am: Yesterday, the judges had refrained from disclosing any details regarding their concerns with the judiciary. They had also stated in their letter to the CJI that it was to âavoid embarrassing the institution.â The lack of detail had led to much speculation yesterday. In response, CPI(M) leader Sitaram Yechury has asked, âSo the case that triggered it all, is about the sudden death of a Judge hearing a serious case involving the BJP President?â His tweet this morning comes with a news article on the probe into the death of Judge Loya.
10.35 am: The judges yesterday, following their address to the media, had made public the letter they wrote to the CJI. In the letter, they had written: âChief Justice is only the first amongst the equals â" nothing more or nothing less.â Read the entire letter here.
10.17 am: In case you missed what happened yesterday, four senior judges of the Supreme Court held a press conference. They said they had written a letter to Chief Justice of India Dipak Misra two months ago about a certain issue, but did not receive any response. Saying that all their efforts have failed, they said âwe are discharging our duties to the nation.â Justice Chelameswar, who spoke on behalf of the group, added that, âTwenty years later, wise men shouldnât say we sold our souls.â
Twenty years later, wise men shouldnât say we sold our souls.
9.55 am: Meanwhile, president of the Bar Vikas Singh has said, âIf they had to come for a press conference, then they should have said something substantial. Just creating doubts in the minds of people will not serve the interest of the judiciary. This was not properly planned. They didnât say anything about Justice Loya.â
9.40 am: The Supreme Court Bar Association is expected to meet, a day after allegations against the institution were made by the top SC judges. They are likely to hold a press conference later today, reported ANI.
9.30 am: A day after four judges of the Supreme Court held a press conference to reveal that âthings are not in orderâ in the judiciary, we bring you all the live updates, reactions and news.
For all the latest In dia News, download Indian Express AppÂ© IE Online Media Services Pvt Ltd Most Read
- FIR against Tribune reporter over Aadhaar data breach story
- Padmavati becomes 'Padmavat', set to clash with Akshay Kumar's PadMan on January 25
- Photos: Anushka Sharma back on the sets of Shah Rukh Khan's Zero after dreamy wedding
- India vs South Africa 1st Test: South Africa beat India by 72 runs
- SC judges' revolt LIVE UPDATES: Bar Council calls for immediate resolution of SC crisis, offers to mediate
- CitiesMumbai: At least five dead as chopper with ONGC employees crashes, search ops underway
- OpinionThe Chief Justice of India is the Master of the Roster. He must also be accountable
- OpinionGrievances about development underlie Balochistan's political crisis
- EntertainmentBigg Boss 11: Nitibha Kaul and Manu Punjabi root for Shilpa Shinde. Watch video
- EntertainmentDeepika, Ranveer, Kareena and others let their hair down at Shah Rukh Khan's party for bestie Kaajal Anand
- EntertainmentTaimur Ali Khan's throwback birthday photo is a perfect start to the weekend. See photo
- TrendingWhat was the most EMBARRASSING moment from your childhood? Twitterati recall hilarious incidents
- TrendingThis kangaroo struck a SEDUCTIVE pose to block the loo; and Twitterati can't get over it
- SportsIPL Auctions: Yuvraj, Gayle, Root lead 1122-name player list
- Army chief not an educationist, we know how to run education system in state: J&K Education Minister
- Varnika Kundu stalking case: Vikas Barala claims innocence, says 'I am the victim'
- Rahul Gandhi to visit Karnataka from Feb 10-12 for first leg of assembly poll campaign
- SportsIndia vs South Africa LIVE SCORE 2nd Test Day 1
- SportsParthiv replaces Saha, Ishant in for Bhuvneshwar
- Priyanka Chopra, Deepika Padukone, Alia Bhatt: Fashion hits and misses of the week (Jan 7 â" Jan 13)
- LifestyleEight months after their uterine transplants, two women ready for assisted pregnancy
- TechnologySamsung Galaxy S9 retail box leaked, reveals Super Speed tech, dual apertures for camera
- TechnologyWhatsApp testing new feature to 'dismiss' someone as group admin: Report
- Angelique Kerber issues Australian Open warning with Sydney International triumph
- Eating muesli in breakfast may help combat arthritis
- Varnika Kundu stalking case: Vikas Barala claims innocence, says âI am the victimâ
- 11 langurs found dead in Rajasthan; police suspect they were beaten, dumped
- Zareen Khan: I have always been a tomboy
- Read Next
- Bigg Boss 11: Manu Punjabi and Nitibha Kaul root for Shilpa Shinde. Watch video
- Seventh GTU convocation: 15-year-old youngest among those who get degrees
- Amazon is said to explore AR as VR gets a lifeline at CES